Close this search box.

Why You Should Think Twice Before Buying an Email List

In the digital marketing world, it's tempting to fast-track your way to a broad audience by purchasing an email list. However, this practice comes with several pitfalls that can seriously undermine your marketing efforts and even put you on the wrong side of the law. Here's why buying an email list is fraught with problems.
An email icon with a red cross over it against a blue digital background, representing the ethical email marketing practices - Email marketing course from Growth Hacking University and Crowthrocks

Table of Contents

Legal Implications and User Consent

First and foremost, it’s essential to understand that while buying an email list isn’t illegal, using that list might be. Sending unsolicited messages to individuals without their express consent contravenes regulations in many countries, such as the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) in the EU and the CAN-SPAM Act in the US. These laws demand that recipients have opted in to receive communications, and failing to comply can lead to hefty fines and legal action.

The Stigma of Spamming

Beyond legality, there’s the perception issue. Sending unsolicited emails is often equated to spamming. When recipients receive something they didn’t sign up for, they’re likely to mark your messages as spam. This negative reaction is not surprising since no one likes unsolicited emails cluttering their inbox.

The Battle of the Inbox

Even if you try to reach out to the recipients on your purchased list, there’s no guarantee your email will make it to the inbox. Many email clients are equipped with sophisticated algorithms that sniff out potential spam, and they might classify your message accordingly, diverting it straight to the spam folder before a recipient even sees it.

Your Sender Reputation is at Stake

Every time your email is marked as spam, it negatively affects your sender reputation. This is a score that Internet Service Providers (ISP) use to determine whether your emails should be delivered to the inbox or not. A poor sender reputation can significantly diminish your email deliverability, and worse, it could result in your email IP being blacklisted.

Email Marketing Services Could Shun You

Finally, the use of purchased lists can be problematic with your email marketing service providers. These platforms are very protective of their infrastructure and overall service reputation. If they detect that you’re using a purchased list, they may refuse to serve you, as it poses a risk to their shared IP pools and can affect the deliverability for all their customers.

In conclusion, while the idea of having immediate access to thousands of potential customers through a purchased email list can be alluring, the cons far outweigh the pros. The risks to your reputation, deliverability, and legal standing make it an unsound business strategy. Instead, focus on building a permission-based list. It takes more time, but the rewards – a highly engaged audience, better deliverability, and compliance with the law – are well worth the effort.

Join our newsletter to stay updated